There is a need for mature politics and mature politicians to work hard to find a realistic solution to the complex Afghan dilemma. Has any one done any serious work on removing many of the problems Afghanistan is facing? And what would be the end result of proposed sometimes covert and hopefully overt talks with Taliban? What would be the effect of Talibani extremism reentering Afghan’s social and political culture?
Socially, politically, militarily, historically and culturally, Afghanistan is not a country that could be forced to submission. Perhaps that is the reason about 20 percent of the world countries who are engaged in one way or another in the war in Afghanistan have, even after nine years of intensive engagement are dreaming of success, a success that has been evading them.
In Afghanistan imposition of democracy has not worked. Intense military intervention has resulted in intense resistance. The wish to defeat corruption has given rise to more and overt corruption implicating many who are in power and in government. Yearning for security even when its President has openly wept in public has increased violence.
While everyone inside Afghanistan and those interested in the world community outside that country know that war lords and warlordism have proven detrimental to the cause of peace and prosperity, yet all in power have done nothing to tame renegade warlords or bring them under the wing of law.
Billions of Dollars were spent in the past nine years in Afghanistan with almost nothing to show for it. Hundreds of foreign troops and thousands of Afghans were killed in direct and indirect conflict including collateral casualties. Mutual trust between foreign troops and Afghan civilians did not establish because of lack of mutually agreed upon coordination and cooperation rules of conduct.
The initial hope of the Afghans, who were liberated from the harsh and dictatorial rule of the Taliban, for peace, security and economic prosperity did not materialize. Instead the warlords and those connected with the government were able to increase their wealth in some instances tens of times over. The Kabul Bank story is only one example where the powerful were given a chance to invest in lucrative projects in Dubai and when the Bank was nearing bankruptcy it was saved by the government and those who had direct interest in the survival of the bank.
The President of Afghanistan now in power for nine years is losing popularity with each passing day. In a way the past nine years have been wasted, some say because of insurgency, because of the uncoordinated conduct of the international forces, because of non-cooperation by Afghanistan’s neighbors. May be most of these reasons are true, but what has the Afghan President and the leading foreign ally of Afghanistan namely the US done to rectify the situation?
Now many Afghans have started to question the sincerity of the international community including the US and the United Nations and the European Union. Many naively expect that the countries of the world at large should forgo their own interests and just fight for Afghanistan. They forget that the true burden of the responsibility for Afghanistan lies on them and no one else. Some on the other hand believe that now that Al-Qaeda has been driven out of Afghanistan, the Afghans should be left alone to solve their own problems. They should have a popular government and that government should be helped with military know how and equipment, but foreign troops should be withdrawn quickly from that country.
Others, uninitiated in world politics think that the world is not helping Afghanistan, but it is hurting it. Democracy remains a dream that originated in Washington D.C. Democratic processes such as the most recent parliamentary elections proved problematic, fraud stricken and inconsequential and may end up with electing of the warlords and the powerful especially the so-called jihadi figures to a legislature that is immature, and ignorant even of the workings of the congress and who are for the most part hated by the public and accused of all sorts of excesses against the innocent and the weak in the society.
Pakistan, supposedly an ally in war on terror, has been caught many times red handed in sabotaging efforts for peace in Afghanistan and the international war on terror in Afghanistan. Closure of the land port of Torkham against military supplies for ISAF is one example. Continued good-will relations between Pakistani ISI and extremists in Pakistan who support Taliban and Talibanism is another example. Yet each year the US is extending millions of Dollars in aid to that country.
And now the concept of talks with the Taliban agreed upon in the London Conference remains a strong hope for the Afghan administration. The United States military is supporting the idea also. Even Pakistan has released Mulla Baradar the second in command of Taliban to play some role in the so-called talks. He was accidentally arrested in Karachi last year and was kept in a comfortable house in Islamabad by the ISI. Talks or no talks the positions of both sides have been publicized over and over again. The Afghan government and its allies are of the opinion that those Taliban who are not accused of crimes must agree to lay down their arms and accept the Afghan constitution. The Taliban have announced time and again that we will be ready to talk only when foreign forces leave the country and Taliban are offered responsible positions in the government. The question is with the support the Taliban receive from their Pakistani friends would they still be interested to work for Karzai’s government. And could Karzai’s government accept the extreme restrictions imposed in the name of Islam on the population and especially women. What would be the real role of the Taliban if they could not dictate their extreme ways?
It would seem that many think Afghanistan is kid’s play. It is not. It requires mature political thought and conduct and above all education of the public.